1. Roles

2. How a Review Is Triggered

The topic creator manually initiates a review on a post within their topic. The system then:

• Randomly selects 12 jurors from eligible community members in the topic
• Sends each selected juror a notification with the voting deadline
• Opens a 24-hour voting window; verdict is issued automatically when it closes

3. Juror Voting

Accessing the Vote

Receive the "You've been selected as a juror" notification → click the link to open the review page.

Voting Rules

• Two options: Remove / Keep
• Reason is optional
• Each juror may cast one vote; votes cannot be changed
• Vote before the deadline shown in the notification — abstentions are recorded if the deadline passes

Point Rewards

• Vote aligns with the final verdict (including appeal outcome) → +5 points
• Vote does not align → 0 points
• ⚠️ For a Remove verdict, juror points are held until the 24-hour appeal window closes

Provisional Hiding

During voting, if the following condition is met, the post is provisionally hidden:

Remove votes > 1 and Remove votes > Keep votes (minimum 2 remove votes required)

• The author receives a "post provisionally hidden" notification and is charged 1 point (trial period; will be 10 points at full launch)
• If subsequent votes break the condition, the post is automatically restored and the 1 point is refunded

4. Verdict

After all 12 votes are cast or the 24-hour window expires, the system issues an automatic verdict:

5. Appeals (Authors Only)

When You Can Appeal

A Remove verdict gives the author two appeal entry points:

① Standard Appeal (voting complete, verdict is Remove)

• Window: within 24 hours of the verdict
• Entry: review page → "Appeal Verdict"

② Provisional-Hide Appeal (voting still in progress, post already hidden)

• No need to wait for voting to finish — you can appeal immediately
• The system settles the current vote: if the result is Remove, the appeal proceeds; if Keep, the post is restored and no appeal is needed

Appeal Cost

Appeal Outcomes

Appeal upheld (verdict overturned):

• Post restored to public visibility
• Stake refunded + provisional hide penalty refunded (if applicable) + 5-point bonus
• Net gain: +5 points

Appeal dismissed (verdict upheld):

• Post remains hidden
• Stake forfeited; provisional hide penalty is not refunded

6. Judge Panel Review

Trigger

Once an appeal is submitted, the system randomly selects 5 judges to conduct the review. The voting window is also 24 hours.

Decision Rule (identical to the juror rule)

Remove votes > 1 and Remove votes > Keep votes → verdict upheld; otherwise → verdict overturned

The final ruling is issued automatically once all 5 judges have voted or the 24-hour window expires.

Point Rewards

• Vote aligns with final ruling → +10 points
• Vote does not align → 0 points

7. Review Status Flow

8. Detailed Flow Diagrams

8.1 Juror Full Flow

8.2 Appeal Full Flow

9. Points Summary

#dao #Community #Review #UserGuide